Audrey Fang case: Spanish judge blocks suspect’s deportation to S’pore over death penalty concerns

An attempt by Spanish immigration authorities to deport Mitchell Ong, the suspect in the fatal stabbing of fellow Singaporean Audrey Fang in Spain, was blocked by a local court over death penalty concerns.

As such, it is unlikely for the 44-year-old to face the death penalty if charged with murder, as a murder charge in Spain carries a jail sentence ranging from 15 years to 25 years.

News of the deportation request being blocked was first reported by Spanish daily La Opinion de Murcia on May 28.

The deportation request was made by Spain’s General Commissariat for Aliens and Borders, a national police agency that manages immigration and border control matters, and was supported by the lawyer representing Ms Fang’s family.

However, a judge ruled that Ong did not meet the criteria outlined in Spain’s laws pertaining to the expulsion of foreigners, one of which states that immediate deportation can take place if an individual has been charged for a crime with a jail sentence fewer than six years, or given an alternate sentencing, such as a fine.

Ong’s lawyer, Ms Maria Jesus Ruiz de Castaneda, had told The Straits Times earlier in May that she is opposing the request.

If the deportation had gone through, the Spanish immigration authority had also requested that Ong be banned from returning to Spain for 10 years.

Ms Ruiz de Castaneda had also earlier told Spanish media that an expulsion would be a violation of the rule of law and international treaties Spain has signed and ratified.

“He is involved in ongoing criminal proceedings in Spain, where he must be tried with due process,” she said. 

“Expulsion would be contrary to the European Convention on Human Rights, the principle of non-refoulement and Spain’s commitments against the death penalty.”

She had previously called for the case to be dismissed, saying all necessary evidence had to be examined and that Ong “firmly and consistently” insisted he did not kill Ms Fang.

The 39-year-old architect was found dead near a parking lot for lorries in the town of Abanilla on April 10, 2024.

She left Singapore on April 4 to travel alone to Xabia in the Valencia region of Spain, and was supposed to return eight days later, but became uncontactable on April 10.

Her body was found with knife wounds and head trauma, and Ong was arrested six days later.

Testimonies from two of Ms Fang’s friends on June 26, 2024, said that Ms Fang and Ong had met on a social dating network, with her family’s lawyer saying that she had told her friends she was meeting the former insurance agent during her holiday in Spain.

In March, La Opinion reported that DNA from two men was found on her clothes, raising the possibility that more than one person was involved in her death.

Ong meanwhile was also found to have been nominated as the sole beneficiary of Ms Fang’s Central Provident Fund savings, with the accounts reportedly containing about $498,000.

ST has contacted the Ministry of Home Affairs for comment.

Source: The Straits Times © SPH Media Limited. Permission required for reproduction.

When squabbling parents turn kids into weapons – and victims: Opinion ADV: Legal Profession Symposium 2025: Redefining the norm